THE NIGHT WE INTERVIEWED AUDREY SEILER ====================================== A True Story from the Glory Days of WSUM Radio Published: October 22, 2026 Author: Dan Conderman Back in April 2004, Madison, Wisconsin, was absolutely consumed by the Audrey Seiler story. Audrey was a UW–Madison student who had gone missing, setting off a massive search and attracting national media attention. She was eventually found, and the whole story took a bizarre turn when investigators determined that her disappearance had been staged. It was the kind of news story that absolutely everybody in Madison was talking about. And the following Friday night, my wife and I decided to have a little fun with it. At the time, I had a radio show on WSUM, the University of Wisconsin–Madison student radio station. We weren't exactly broadcasting to millions of people. As far as we could tell, our regular audience consisted of about four cab drivers and a house party somewhere in Madison. But we were on the air, and that was all that mattered. So we decided that my wife would come into the studio and play Audrey Seiler, appearing for an exclusive interview. The joke was simple: Audrey supposedly wanted to be famous, and now she'd finally made it onto the radio. Unfortunately, nothing about her newfound celebrity status was quite good enough for her. She was playing an absolutely spoiled brat. She complained about the studio lighting. The lighting. In a radio studio. She didn't like the microphones. She wasn't happy with the accommodations. Everything was beneath her. She was finally a celebrity, damn it, and she expected to be treated like one. And every time I tried to get the interview moving, she'd find another reason to complain. She also had a particular Pink song that she insisted was her theme music. So she'd demand that I play it. I'd pot up the music, and it would cover our conversation. Eventually, we'd come back, I'd try to ask another question, and she'd find something else wrong. Then she'd want her theme music again. The entire gag was that we had supposedly landed this incredible exclusive interview with the most talked-about woman in Wisconsin, but she was so impossibly difficult that we couldn't get her to answer a single question. We thought it was hilarious. And we figured it was so obviously a ridiculous student-radio comedy bit that nobody could possibly mistake it for anything else. Remember, this was happening just days after she had been found. The story was still fresh. The newspapers were full of it. Everybody knew who Audrey Seiler was. We finished the show, went home, and that was that. Or so we thought. The next day, the Wisconsin State Journal called our station manager. They wanted to know how WSUM had managed to land an exclusive interview with Audrey Seiler. Apparently, somebody had heard about our broadcast, and the newspaper was genuinely interested in how a little student radio station had gotten access to a woman who wasn't granting interviews. I can only imagine the conversation. Here were professional journalists trying to get to the bottom of one of the biggest local news stories of the year, and somehow they'd gotten word that WSUM had scored the interview. Meanwhile, the actual interview had consisted of my wife complaining about the lighting, criticizing the microphones, and repeatedly demanding that I play her Pink song. Not one useful question answered. Not one meaningful revelation. Just an imaginary celebrity throwing a tantrum in front of an audience of four cab drivers and a house party. And somehow, we'd made the newspaper curious. That was the beauty of student radio. You didn't need a budget. You didn't need a production staff. You didn't need permission from a network executive. You needed a microphone, a little imagination, somebody willing to play along, and an FCC license belonging to someone else. For one Friday night in April 2004, we had the hottest exclusive interview in Madison. And the woman we interviewed wasn't even there. That was radio. — Dan Conderman Former WSUM Radio Host